
For those of us who teach, we all seem to suffer that familiar experience of immediately finishing a message and asking with the question: “How did I do?”. If you’re like me, you’re attempting to pull together all of the verbal and nonverbal cues from the audience during the course of the last 20-35 minutes you’ve just spent teaching. Usually, I’ll give myself a passing grade if I feel like less than 25% of the room was text-messaging their friends during that time.
Of course, the super-spiritual among us are quick to self-correct: “It is not me who gives the message, but God’s Spirit through me”. Sure. I’m sure we all can connect with that idea. It’s just a bit problematic when I start grading His effectiveness. Certainly, the Holy Spirit moving in and throughout the lives of the students can’t be boring. But, then, if it’s Him giving the message why are the students playing paper football with the bulletin? Does he get a failing grade?
Then I start to wonder… Usually, I’m crippled with a bit of guilt about the whole thing. I’m not spiritual enough to do what I ought (not care about how people respond to me) and I feel like I’m holding on way tightly to the emotionally charged feedback from the students in the room. In many cases, I think to myself, “Either I’m not good enough as a teacher or I’m not spiritual enough to be one.”
Then, after receiving a self-assessed failing grade only 3 seconds after leaving the stage, a student approaches.
Crap.
I know what’s coming. Something like: “I didn’t really get what you were saying” or “I’m one of the elders’ kids, I have some issues with your position on supralapsarianism” or “This was much better than usual — once you got over that stuttering problem” (I’ve gotten this one before. I didn’t know I had much of a stuttering problem. Now, I’m self-c-c-c-conscious about it).
She says, “Thank you so much. I needed to hear that. You always do a great job.”
Always? That’s a lie. I think she was “up” 10 to 6 in paper football at about 5 minutes in.
Somehow, however, I get that ultra-frustrating reality that God may not actually be speaking per se, but using the message to accomplish His stuff. For that, I cannot take the blame for a weak message (fortunately) nor can I take the credit for one that “does something” (unfortunately for me).